Abs Skid

This forum is for the open and public discussion of Accident Reconstruction topics. This is open to any registered user of the CrashForum.info site. Administrator: Sean Haight Moderators: Bill Redfairn (wredfairn), Wade Bartlett (wade_b), Wes Vandiver (WVandiver), Bruce McNally (actar670), George Hall (George_Hall)

Abs Skid

Postby Dwight » Sat Apr 14, 2012 3:45 pm

Why is it everyone says ABS brakes do not skid, when in fact they do indeed skid. Although not a continual skid like brakes before ABS, but lets say more like a skip skid that you would find from an empty dump truck. If you try heavy breaking on a gravel road you will see the results and the fact that they do indeed skid.
Dwight Magee CAI
Certified Accident Investigator
User avatar
Dwight
 
Posts: 16
Joined: Sat Apr 14, 2012 3:22 pm
First Name: Dwight
Last Name: Magee

Re: Abs Skid

Postby Rusty Haight » Sat Apr 14, 2012 9:28 pm

Dwight:
Perhaps the hardest thing we do as human beings is something we think we do all the time: communicate. One of the fundamentals of communication is that we have a common language. In this case, that may be at the root of some confusion here. "ABS" and "skidding" aren't necessarily exclusive concepts.

First, ABS is the acronym for "anti-lock brake system." In a nutshell, ABS works by monitoring wheel speed and when the system sees the wheel speed go to zero (0) - where the wheel is locked - the ABS system releases the wheel and then reapplies braking to the point where again the wheel is locked and slipping relative to the road, then releases it again and it does that over and over, for some systems, as much as 15 times per second. Yes, there is a period where the wheel(s) are locked but it's for a very short period and the cycle rate is so high it's not something easily seen by the naked eye. The underlying concept behind ABS effectiveness is that a wheel at "threshold" - the point right before it fully locks and slips and the wheel speed goes to 'zero" - is slowing the vehicle more effectively than one where the wheel speed is zero and the tire is sliding on the road in full slip (the wheel speed stays at zero).

Here's where the user's intent or meaning of a word is important: we should be talking here about a difference between "slipping" or "skidding" relative to the road and "effective threshold braking."

So, what's a "skid?" In your post, you wrote:
... If you try heavy breaking on a gravel road you will see the results and the fact that they do indeed skid...
What you might be referring to as a "skid" others in reconstruction might be more inclined to call "furrowing" in the gravel road example. Normally, a "skid (mark)" is a mark left by a locked wheel. We see the results of non-ABS equipped cars braking and skidding on pavement in the form of "tire marks" which are generally a combination of molten rubber from a locked and sliding tire combined, in some cases, with roadway materials like tar or oils resulting in what we can call "skid marks" or "tire friction marks."

In your example, on a gravel road, the ABS equipped braking vehicle is locking and releasing the tire(S) so fast that the tires are essentially pushing dirt along as the vehicle slows toward a stop. The "marks" aren't "skid" marks in the traditional sense (like you might find on a paved road from non-ABS equipped vehicles) they're simply a displacement of the gravel as the tires are being slowed and released then slowed again. But the furrowing doesn't "prove" an ABS system allows the wheels to lock up during braking.

Now, in terms of what you might think of as "skid marks" on a paved road from ABS equipped vehicles, no, ABS equipped vehicles don't leave "traditional" locked wheel marks and that may be part of the source of some of the confusion here: the difference between the appearance of a non-ABS equipped vehicle's tire marks and those left by a vehicle with ABS. In heavy, ABS-assisted braking, an ABS equipped vehicle will leave faint, short lived marks on the pavement which - depending on the type of pavement among other things - might be relatively harder to see on some roads.

At the end of the day, ABS equipped vehicles do leave "tire marks" during heavy braking but they don't have the same appearance characteristics as marks left by non-ABS equipped vehicles. A properly functioning ABS equipped vehicle will lock and release the tires during heavy braking and that effects the appearance of the marks these wheels leave. But, and maybe this goes to the heart of the question, the appearance of a "tire mark" (on the pavement or on the road) isn't, by itself, an indication of tires being locked or not.

Going back to your gravel road example, try this: Drive down a DIRT road over a part of the road with other tire marks. Look at the marks left by your car. You'll see the tread pattern left by your tires. Now drive back through the same area but this time, go into full on ABS-assisted braking. Now look at the characteristics of those marks. Note that the tread pattern's no longer distinguishable as it was in the case of the rolling wheel, no braking drive through. If you can, find a non-ABS equipped vehicle and do the same hard braking and compare the characteristics - on the dirt road - of the ABS-assisted and non-ABS-assisted hard braking marks. I suspect you'll see there aren't really any differences between the two.
- Rusty Haight
Collision Safety Institute
User avatar
Rusty Haight
 
Posts: 162
Joined: Tue May 10, 2011 12:24 pm
First Name: W. R. Rusty
Last Name: Haight

Re: Abs Skid

Postby Dwight » Sun Apr 15, 2012 6:22 am

In 1995 the Palm Beach County Sheriffs department Vehicle Homicide Unit conducted an ABS workshop. The purpose was to identify what type of evidence an ABS stop might leave.

Two identical vehicles, 1993 Chev Caprices one with ABS and one without, were the test vehicles. The test speeds were timed with radar and all marks were photographed and measured.

On various test surfaces ABS marks were lighter and harder to see than skid marks.

Though much less apparent than skid marks, every dry surface left a clearly defined measurable ABS mark. The beginning of the ABS mark was well defined. Everyone could agree on the ABS mark length. Interestingly, in every dry ABS test, the tires showed conclusive evidence of the stop.

The tires faces were speckled with longitudinally oriented circumferential marks. These markings are similar to the striations on a yawing tire face, but shorter and oriented along the tire axis. This speckling was more apparent on the front tires than the rear.

You could not discern the front wheels from the rear wheels in the ABS marks. Abs marks were of inconsistent darkness along their length. There were dark and light sections within the mark.

ABS marks are short lived evidence after 24 hrs on a very lightly traveled road. Only 2 of the 7 tests were still measurable.

ABS marks are best viewed at a distance, at an angle in the direction of travel of the vehicle.
link to test http://www.tarorigin.com/art/absscuff/index.html

One more thing... here is an attachment of marks on a hard packed gravel rd.
Attachments
ABS Skid Marks on Gravel by DM.docx
Hard packed gravel ABS marks
(499.57 KiB) Downloaded 280 times
Dwight Magee CAI
Certified Accident Investigator
User avatar
Dwight
 
Posts: 16
Joined: Sat Apr 14, 2012 3:22 pm
First Name: Dwight
Last Name: Magee

Re: Abs Skid

Postby Dwight » Sun Apr 15, 2012 8:43 am

Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol. 6, pp. 3401 - 3412, 2005
Attachments
ABS Skid.docx
(499.57 KiB) Downloaded 282 times
Dwight Magee CAI
Certified Accident Investigator
User avatar
Dwight
 
Posts: 16
Joined: Sat Apr 14, 2012 3:22 pm
First Name: Dwight
Last Name: Magee


Return to Public Reconstruction Discussion

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 1 guest